Who Pays Closing Costs: How to Negotiate Mortgage Fees

Couple Paying Mortgage Closing Costs

Finding the home of your dreams is hard enough. Funding the home of your dreams can be just as a difficult. Let’s this be your roadmap to who pays the closing costs for your new mortgage.

Non-negotiables

There’s no such thing as a zero-fee mortgage. Any lender that tries to convince you otherwise is either lying or distorting the process of rolling the cash value of closing costs into the overall balance of the mortgage you’ll be paying monthly. Be careful if you choose to go this route: $1,000 compounded monthly at today’s 4.25% average rate for a 30-year mortgage rises to $3,570.65 over the life of the loan.

More often you’ll be on the hook for several thousand dollars in closing costs of one form or another. Expect to pay these fees every time:

  • Title search or exam fees for checking and filing the necessary paperwork with the government.
  • Title insurance to ensure the lender doesn’t get stuck paying for unfiled paperwork to bring the property into compliance with state, federal, and local laws.
  • Property tax because Uncle Sam gets his cut regardless of where you live. (But you’ll pay more if you live in a high-rent area.)
  • Flood determination which you’ll pay if you live in an area that’s prone to floodings, such as parts of Florida and Louisiana.
  • Credit report fee because your lender has a right to understand your credit score and history before lending you money.
  • Attorney fees because some states mandate an attorney be present when signing closing documents, and attorneys aren’t free.
  • Prepaid interest because if you have a mortgage, you need to pay interest. What you’ll pay up front depends on the day of the month in which you close and move in. The later in the month, the less interest you’ll pay upfront.

Specific mortgage fees

Some fees depend on the product you’re using. For example, applicants with bad credit may need a mortgage backed by the Federal Housing Authority (FHA), but that product comes with an upfront mortgage insurance commitment equal to roughly 2.25% of the financed amount. It also includes a monthly fee. Similarly, active duty military and veterans who qualify for a VA loan may have to pay a VA funding fee. This may be up to 3.3% of the total loan amount.

Don’t get too frightened by these fees. Wounded warriors with a disability rating may be eligible to waive the VA funding fee. And while the FHA payments are non-negotiable, your lender may have options for reducing your out-of-pocket commitment to insurance premiums. A good lender will always for getting you into the house you want and the mortgage you need.

Negotiable closing costs

Other fees are either optional or unnecessary. Or, there’s wide discretion in how they get levied. Be vigilant in negotiating these closing costs:

  • Origination fees because they’re entirely at the discretion of your lender, and designed to create a bit of profit padding in the event the total loan amount is too low to make writing the loan worthwhile.
  • Appraisal fees, which are technically mandatory. Why list it then? The price you pay for an appraisal is negotiable. Don’t let your lender stick you with a high-priced appraiser who charges a premium for a 15-minute walk-through. Also: ask for a copy of the appraisal. And ask if you can pay at closing time rather than upfront.
  • Home inspection fees because these sometimes get added in for refinancings but only apply to purchases. If you’re buying a pre-existing home, the buyer may choose not to pay for a home inspection and the seller may choose not to offer one.
  • Escrow is also optional if you’re getting a conventional mortgage. Just be careful. Choosing not to pay taxes and insurance monthly doesn’t remove the obligation of paying those fees. You’ll just have to pay them directly at the appropriate time of year.
  • Application fees because they’re another way lenders maneuver to get a little extra cash from every deal. And they’re probably making plenty of profit already.

Pre-qualify in 10 minutes

By submitting this form, I am providing express consent for American Financing to contact me, including through the use of an automated dialer, voice or text, at the number above, even if my telephone number is listed on any Do-Not-Call list. I understand that I do not have to consent to receive such calls or text messages in order to purchase goods or services from American Financing.

Weird fees you might have to pay if …

Sometimes you’ll pay fees for largely inexplicable reasons. Take real estate transfer taxes, which are usually (but not always) paid when a property changes hands and a new title issued. If you live in one of these 37 states or the District of Columbia, you may be on the hook for a transfer tax.

What you’ll pay varies on where you live. Here in Colorado, fees tend to max out under $200. But in Washington state, you could pay 1.28% of the sale price of your home plus local taxes. So, if you live in Seattle and sell a primary residence for $500,000, over $6,000 of your expected proceeds could find their way to government coffers instead. Sound maddening? You bet it is.

Remember the bottom line

Fees are inevitable; you’ll pay them wherever you live and whatever property you’re buying or selling. So, take time to enjoy the process! Burdening yourself with the stress of nitpicking every fee on your Closing Disclosure (the lender must supply this to you) can suck the joy out of home buying.

Pick your spots. Save as much as you can. And then focus on closing your loan and getting the keys. Because as soon as you go through that front door, who paid which closing costs won’t matter as much as closing the deal to get your dream home.